How to Kill a Border Town

With all the efforts to increase security at the US/Canada border, nobody has been more inconvenienced than border communities. These communities that have grown up seeing their southern or northern neighbours as an extension of themselves are now faced with a new reality; one that includes formality, documentation, and increased police presence.

Consider the communities of Stanstead Quebec and Derby Line Vermont. The image below shows the two border communities. The red line is the US/Canada border. The yellow lines are examples of streets that flow naturally between the two communities, as if it was all built as one village…which it probably was.

 (Click to enlarge)

Over to the right, just off the image, is the *official* border crossing location, although from the articles I’ve read there seem to be other border crossing stations throughout the town.

Over the past while the community of Derby Line has seen an increase in police presence, in part because of Operation Stone Garden: an initiative to ask state and local police officers to help assist patrolling the town on behalf of the CBP.

This community has been highlighted twice in the past month, and citizens of both countries have been the recipients of the US DHS’s increased security measures.

Nova Scotia Couple’s Horrible Wrong Turn

The CBC story covers all the details, but in a nutshell:

- Couple dropped off son at his boarding school in Stanstead.
- Driving through the town & looking at buildings, they took a left turn
- They unknowingly entered the US and were stopped by police.

From the article:

"They called border patrol, and immediately, three or four border patrol trucks came and escorted us [to the customs office]."

The couple was escorted to the official, marked border crossing, which is on the main street that runs north-south through both towns.

The U.S. Customs and Border Protection officers were not sympathetic to the Zwaagstras explanation of how they had innocently crossed the border into the U.S., said Don Zwaagstra.

"They suggested that we could be fined; we could have our vehicle impounded; we could be arrested, deported, a number of things," he said. "You know, a couple of those types of insinuations, and it depended a lot on how our criminal records checked out."

In the end, the Zwaagstra were simply escorted back to Canada — after they were fingerprinted, photographed and forced to sign documents admitting what they had done.

"I couldn't believe it was happening, and I was totally humiliated," Nancy Zwaagstra said. "I was fingerprinted; I had my mug shot taken. It was a terrible feeling."

Two Canadians who unknowingly crossed over on a street with no visible signage about the location of the border, treated like criminals for simply making the wrong turn at a border town.

American Pharmacist and an Expensive Pizza

Consider the story of Roland “Buzz” Roy, an American from Derby Line charged with illegally crossing the border for getting a pizza from a Canadian restaurant. WCAX-3 ran a story about it:

 

What this highlights is that while Canadians might experience unpleasantness crossing into the US, Americans are exposed to the same experience. Notice that it wasn’t the Canadian security officers that arrested Roland, it was American police.

What Does It All Mean?

For starters, it means the end of the border town. The border is the border, and must be respected as such. Unfortunately, that means drastic changes for communities that for so long have strived to live without noticing that they passed into a different country on a daily basis. For all of the DHS rhetoric about working with border communities, this is a clear example of how they really haven’t understood what the intricacies of border communities really are.

Operation Stone Garden that I mentioned has $60 million US federal dollars backing it…that’s $60 million being spent on overtime for police officers from non-CBP agencies to come up and aid in patrols, catching Canadians who take wrong turns and Americans strolling down the street for a pizza.

In the end, what this means is that if you can you should just avoid border communities at all costs. The treatment and expense a wrong turn can cause is too much risk.

Links

The Raw Story – Border Patrol Arrests Man for Crossing Street

Burlington Free Press – Arrest and New Border Crossing Rules Irritate Derby Line

CBC – N.S. Couple Nabbed After Mistakenly Straying into U.S.